Resignation Without Notice: When Can an Employee Leave Without Being Liable for Damages?

Resignation without notice – resignation letter next to the Romanian Labour Code

An employee is not obliged to remain in employment under any circumstances, nor can they be compelled to continue the employment relationship against their will. The Romanian Labour Code expressly provides for the possibility of resignation without notice, but the exercise of this right must be assessed in light of the employer’s obligations and the possible financial consequences of terminating the employment relationship.

In practice, situations frequently arise in which an employee finds another job, wishes to end the employment relationship immediately or no longer wishes to continue working because of the employer’s conduct.

Employers often invoke the obligation to observe the notice period and threaten employees with having to pay compensation for the damage they might cause by leaving before it expires.

But is it lawful for the employer to automatically claim compensation because the employee did not observe the notice period? Can the employee terminate the individual employment contract immediately? And under what conditions can this right be exercised without the risk of financial consequences?

1. Resignation – a Unilateral Right of the Employee

Under Article 81(1) of Law No. 53/2003 – the Labour Code, resignation is the unilateral act of will by which the employee, through a written notice, informs the employer that the individual employment contract is terminated upon expiry of a notice period.

A first important aspect is the unilateral nature of resignation. It is not a request addressed to the employer and does not require the employer’s approval in order to produce legal effects.

Consequently, the employer cannot refuse the resignation, nor can it make its registration conditional on accepting the reasons given by the employee.

Moreover, under Article 81(3) of the Labour Code, the employee is entitled not to state the reasons for resigning. However, where the employee intends to rely on the exception allowing resignation without notice, it is advisable to expressly state the legal basis and the employer’s obligations that have not been fulfilled.

The notice period is the one set out in the individual employment contract or, where applicable, in the applicable collective labour agreement, and may not exceed 20 working days for employees in non-managerial positions and 45 working days for employees in managerial positions.

2. When Can an Employee Resign Without Notice?

The main exception to the obligation to observe the notice period is set out in Article 81(8) of the Labour Code:

“The employee may resign without notice if the employer fails to fulfil the obligations assumed under the individual employment contract.”

This provision grants the employee the right to terminate the employment relationship without serving the notice period where the employer fails to comply with its contractual obligations.

Depending on the specific circumstances, several situations may fall into this category:

a) Non-payment or Late Payment of Wages

One of the most common situations is the failure to pay wages on the date set out in the individual employment contract, the collective labour agreement or the internal regulations.

Under Article 166 of the Labour Code, wages are paid in money at least once a month, on the date set out in the documents governing the employment relationship.

Non-payment of wages is a breach of an essential obligation of the employer and may justify exercising the right to resign without notice.

b) Failure to Observe the Working Conditions Agreed in the Contract

The employer is obliged to provide adequate conditions for carrying out the work and to respect the employee’s rights.

A unilateral and unjustified change to essential elements of the employment relationship, failure to observe the agreed working conditions or failure to grant contractual rights may, depending on the seriousness and circumstances of the situation, constitute grounds for invoking Article 81(8).

c) Breach of Occupational Health and Safety Obligations

The employer is obliged to ensure the safety and health of workers in every aspect related to work.

A breach of contractual obligations concerning occupational health and safety may be a relevant ground for terminating the employment relationship without notice, provided the legal conditions are met.

d) Failure to Grant Contractual Entitlements

Failure to grant bonuses, allowances, benefits or other entitlements agreed in the individual employment contract or in the collective labour agreement may also amount to a breach of the employer’s obligations.

It should be noted that not every grievance of the employee or every minor irregularity automatically justifies resignation without notice. A specific obligation of the employer must be identified, and it must be established how that obligation was breached.

Employee handing a resignation notice to the employer

3. Is the Employer’s Approval Required for Resignation Without Notice?

No.

Resignation, including resignation under Article 81(8) of the Labour Code, is a unilateral act of will.

The employer has no right to make the legal effects of the resignation conditional on its consent, nor can it refuse to register the notice.

In practice, to avoid potential disputes, we recommend that the notice be made in writing and sent by a means that allows proof of delivery and of the date of delivery.

If the employer refuses to register the resignation, the employee may prove that it was communicated by any means of evidence, in accordance with Article 81(2) of the Labour Code.

It is important that the notice clearly states that the employee is exercising the right to resign without notice under Article 81(8), together with the facts that justify this step.

4. Can the Employer Claim Compensation if the Employee Leaves Without Notice?

This is one of the most important legal issues concerning resignation.

The mere fact that the employee stops working without observing the notice period does not automatically give rise to an obligation to pay compensation to the employer.

Under Article 254(1) of the Labour Code, employees are financially liable, on the basis of the rules and principles of contractual civil liability, for material damage caused to the employer through their fault and in connection with their work.

Therefore, for financial liability to arise, the specific conditions of contractual liability must be met: an unlawful act, certain material damage, the employee’s fault and a causal link between the act and the damage.

Consequently, the employer cannot demand payment of a sum of money merely because the employee did not work during the notice period.

For example, the mere need to hire someone else, the organisational difficulties caused by the employee’s departure or the employer’s dissatisfaction with the timing of the termination are not, in themselves, sufficient to justify an award of compensation.

The employer must prove the existence of specific material damage and that the other legal conditions for financial liability are met.

5. Can the Employer Impose a Penalty for Failure to Observe the Notice Period?

The employer cannot validly set an automatic penalty for the mere failure to observe the notice period.

Decision No. 19/2019 of the High Court of Cassation and Justice is relevant here. It held that a penalty clause in the individual employment contract or in an addendum, which assesses in advance the damage caused to the employer by the employee through their fault and in connection with their work, is prohibited and null and void.

This solution is based, among other things, on Article 38 of the Labour Code, under which employees cannot waive the rights granted to them by law.

Therefore, a contractual clause under which the employee undertakes to pay a fixed sum if they do not observe the notice period cannot replace the legal conditions for financial liability.

The employer may seek compensation for actual damage that has been proven and is attributable to the employee, but it cannot turn this possibility into an automatic financial sanction.

Penalty clause in an individual employment contract declared null and void

6. What Happens if the Employee Leaves Without Notice but the Conditions of Article 81(8) Are Not Met?

An important distinction must be drawn between resignation without notice justified by the employer’s failure to fulfil its obligations and a situation in which the employee simply decides to stop coming to work.

If the conditions of Article 81(8) are not met, the employee must observe the applicable notice period.

During the notice period, the individual employment contract continues to produce all its effects, in accordance with Article 81(5) of the Labour Code. Consequently, the employee remains obliged to work, and the employer must pay the corresponding wages.

Unjustified absence from work may constitute a disciplinary offence and may lead to the sanctions provided by law, subject to the disciplinary procedure.

In addition, if the employer proves that material damage was caused under the conditions of Article 254 of the Labour Code, it may claim compensation for it.

Therefore, simply sending a notice titled “resignation without notice” does not guarantee that the employee is released from all legal consequences. The legal ground invoked must be genuine and supported by the specific circumstances of the employment relationship.

7. Are There Other Situations in Which an Employee Can Leave Without Notice?

Yes. Another important situation is the termination of the individual employment contract during the probationary period.

Under Article 31(3) of the Labour Code, during or at the end of the probationary period, the individual employment contract may be terminated solely by written notice, without a notice period, at the initiative of either party, with no need to state reasons.

This form of termination is legally distinct from resignation and does not require invoking a failure by the employer to fulfil its obligations.

Another possibility is the employer’s full or partial waiver of the notice period, in accordance with Article 81(7) of the Labour Code. In this case, the employee may stop working earlier, without having to show a contractual breach by the employer.

8. Our Recommendations for Employees and Employers

Employees who intend to resign without notice should first review their individual employment contract, identify the obligations breached by the employer and keep the documents that can prove the situation they rely on.

The notice must be sent in writing, stating the legal basis and, where applicable, the reasons that justify exercising the right under Article 81(8) of the Labour Code.

For employers, it is important that any financial claims are based on actual damage and on meeting the legal conditions for the employee’s liability, not on the mere formal breach of the notice period.

Employers should also avoid including contractual clauses that set fixed penalties for an employee leaving before the notice period expires.

Conclusions

Resignation without notice is a right recognised by the Labour Code, but it must be exercised in compliance with the conditions laid down by law.

An employee may terminate the employment relationship without serving the notice period where the employer fails to fulfil the obligations assumed under the individual employment contract. At the same time, the employer cannot automatically claim compensation simply because the employee left without notice.

Financial liability requires the existence and proof of material damage, fault and a causal link, under the conditions laid down by the Labour Code.

Author: P.A.

Views: 11