Untaken Annual Leave: When It Is Lost and When the Employer Must Pay for It

Untaken Annual Leave: When It Is Lost and When the Employer Must Pay for It

One of the questions that frequently arises in employment relationships concerns what happens to annual leave days left untaken at the end of the year: are they lost, carried over, or must the employer pay for them?

The answer cannot be reduced to the rule, often invoked in practice, that leave days “expire after 18 months”. The Labour Code does lay down an 18-month period for granting leave not taken for justified reasons, but the application of this limit must also be assessed in light of the actual conduct of the employer and the employee.

Moreover, by Decision No 40 of 9 March 2026, the High Court of Cassation and Justice clarified both the conditions under which the entitlement may survive after the 18-month period has expired and the point from which the limitation period for claiming an allowance in lieu starts to run.

1. The rule: annual leave must be taken every year

The right to paid annual leave is guaranteed to all employees and, under Article 144(2) of the Labour Code, may not be assigned, waived or restricted.

The rule, therefore, is not payment for leave days, but actually taking annual leave.

This conclusion also follows expressly from Article 146(1) of the Labour Code, under which annual leave is to be taken every year.

In addition, Article 149 of the Labour Code requires the employee to take leave in kind during the period for which it was scheduled, except in the cases provided for by law or where, for objective reasons, the leave cannot be taken.

Annual leave should therefore not be viewed as a financial benefit that the employee may choose to convert into money. Its purpose is to ensure an actual period of rest.

2. What happens to leave days that have not been taken?

The fact that the calendar year has ended does not, in itself, result in the automatic loss of untaken leave days.

Article 146(2) of the Labour Code governs the situation in which the employee, for justified reasons, was unable to take all or part of the annual leave to which they were entitled.

In this situation, with the employee’s agreement, the employer must grant the untaken leave within a period of 18 months starting from the year following the one in which the leave entitlement arose.

For example, if an employee was unable to take all the leave days for 2025 for justified reasons, the mere start of 2026 does not result in their loss. They may be granted under the carry-over period provided for by law.

It is important to note, however, that carry-over should not become the normal way in which the employment relationship operates. The primary obligation remains to organise and take leave in the year for which it is due.

3. Are the 18 months a time limit after which leave is automatically lost?

This is one of the most important practical issues.

On a first reading of Article 146(2) of the Labour Code, one might conclude that, once the 18-month carry-over period has expired, untaken leave days disappear.

Such a conclusion, however, is too categorical.

What must be examined is why the leave was not taken and, in particular, whether the employer actually gave the employee the opportunity to take it.

This distinction follows both from the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union and, now expressly for domestic law, from ÎCCJ Decision No 40/2026.

In other words, merely recording a leave balance in the company’s documents and the mere passage of time are not always sufficient to conclude that the employee’s entitlement has been extinguished.

CONCEDIU DE ODIHNĂ

4. What did the ÎCCJ rule in Decision No 40/2026?

By Decision No 40 of 9 March 2026, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, No 665 of 11 August 2026, the High Court of Cassation and Justice – Panel for the Resolution of Questions of Law – settled an important issue concerning the allowance in lieu of untaken annual leave.

The referral arose from the question of when the three-year limitation period starts to run for monetary claims relating to leave days not taken by the time the employment or service relationship ends. The issue was relevant precisely because, under Article 146(3) of the Labour Code, an allowance in lieu is possible only upon termination of the employment relationship.

The right to an allowance in lieu arises upon termination of the employment relationship

The High Court held that the right of action for an allowance in lieu of untaken leave arises at the time the employment relationship ends, because only then does the employer’s obligation to pay this allowance fall due.

As long as the individual employment contract is ongoing, the employee cannot claim the monetary value of the leave instead of taking it. During this period, the rule remains that leave is granted in kind.

But what about days older than 18 months?

This is probably the most important clarification in the ruling.

The High Court starts from the rule that, after the carry-over period has expired, the leave entitlement may be regarded as extinguished, so that the days in question can neither be taken in kind nor be compensated in money upon termination of the employment relationship.

This rule does not, however, operate automatically.

Having regard to the case law of the CJEU, the High Court states that an acquired right to paid annual leave cannot be extinguished merely by the expiry of the reference period or the carry-over period where the employee was not actually in a position to take the leave.

It is for the employer to ensure, specifically and transparently, that the employee is actually given the opportunity to take leave, including by informing the employee, accurately and in good time, of the consequences of not taking it.

Conversely, if the employee deliberately refrained from taking leave, in full knowledge of the consequences and after the employer had actually given them the opportunity to take it, the entitlement may be lost.

In the operative part of Decision No 40/2026, the High Court summarises this distinction as follows: for the period exceeding the 18-month carry-over limit, the right to an allowance in lieu survives if the employer did not actually provide the opportunity to exercise the right and does not survive if the employee did not take the leave even though that opportunity was provided.

The practical consequence: the conduct of both parties must be examined

Accordingly, where there are very old leave days, simply checking the date on which they were acquired is not enough.

It must be established, among other things:

  • whether the leave was actually scheduled;
  • whether the employee was specifically given the opportunity to take it;
  • whether the employee was informed of the risk of losing the untaken days;
  • whether the employee requested to take the leave;
  • whether the request was refused or postponed by the employer;
  • whether there were objective reasons that prevented the leave from being taken;
  • or, on the contrary, whether the employee unjustifiably refused to take leave that had actually been made available.

The High Court expressly states that, for periods exceeding the carry-over period, the court must examine whether the employee was at fault and whether there was any fault on the part of the employer, including in terms of failing to inform the employee and failing to provide a genuine opportunity to take the leave.

5. When can untaken annual leave be paid out?

The rule laid down in Article 146(3) of the Labour Code is categorical:

an allowance in lieu of untaken annual leave is permitted only where the individual employment contract is terminated.

Accordingly, for as long as the employment relationship exists, the employer and the employee cannot validly agree that the employee will give up leave in exchange for a sum of money.

From this perspective, the manner in which the contract ends is irrelevant: resignation, dismissal, mutual agreement, retirement, expiry of a fixed-term contract and so on. If, on the termination date, there are untaken leave days for which the entitlement survives, they must be taken into account for the allowance in lieu.

6. When does the 3-year limitation period start to run?

This issue, too, received an express answer in ÎCCJ Decision No 40/2026.

The High Court held that, for monetary claims relating to untaken leave days, the 3-year limitation period starts to run from the time the employment relationship ends, in so far as the entitlement still exists.

The explanation is logical: the employee cannot claim an allowance in lieu while the employment relationship is ongoing. The right to this allowance falls due only upon termination of the employment relationship.

It is essential, however, not to confuse two separate matters:

the limitation of the right of action and the existence of the right to compensation for leave days.

The fact that the three-year period starts to run upon termination of the employment relationship does not mean that, at that point, the employee can automatically claim the value of all the leave days accumulated throughout the entire employment relationship.

For days exceeding the statutory carry-over period, it must be verified whether the entitlement has survived, according to the criteria established by the ÎCCJ: in essence, whether the failure to take the leave is attributable to the employer or to the employee.

CONCEDIU DE ODIHNĂ

7. A practical example

Suppose that an individual employment contract ends in September 2026 and the employer’s records show that the employee still has untaken leave days relating to several years.

The employer should neither automatically assume that all the days shown in the balance must be paid, nor automatically remove the older days by relying on the mere expiry of the 18-month period.

For days exceeding the carry-over period, the specific situation must be examined.

If the employer can prove that it scheduled the leave, gave the employee a genuine opportunity to take it, informed the employee properly and that, despite this, the employee deliberately chose not to take the leave, the entitlement for that period may be regarded as extinguished.

If, however, the leave accumulated because the employer repeatedly refused the employee’s requests, did not create the conditions necessary for the leave to be taken or cannot prove that it actually gave the employee the opportunity to take it, the mere expiry of the 18-month period is not sufficient to extinguish the entitlement.

8. Who is responsible for ensuring that leave is taken?

Annual leave is not the employee’s responsibility alone.

The employer is required to schedule leave and, more importantly in light of recent case law, must be able to prove that the employee was genuinely given the opportunity to exercise the right.

ÎCCJ Decision No 40/2026 emphasises precisely the importance of this active conduct on the part of the employer.

From a practical perspective, a simple provision in the internal regulations stating that employees are required to take their leave, or a purely formal leave schedule, might not be sufficient in every case.

For employers, it becomes important to document how leave is scheduled, communicated and actually made available to the employee.

9. What should employers do in practice?

In light of ÎCCJ Decision No 40/2026, companies should pay closer attention to accumulated leave balances and not leave the matter solely for the time the contract ends.

Employers are advised to:

  • draw up and document the leave schedule;
  • periodically monitor leave balances, especially those carried over from previous years;
  • inform employees of the days still available;
  • actually give them the opportunity to schedule and take leave;
  • document situations in which the employee repeatedly refuses or fails to take leave;
  • keep evidence of communications and schedules;
  • review older leave days individually before treating them as extinguished;
  • upon termination of the contract, determine the balance that represents a subsisting entitlement and must be compensated in money.

This documentation may prove decisive in any litigation, since the High Court has stated that it must be verified whether the employer fulfilled its obligation to create the conditions necessary for leave to be taken and whether the employee, despite having that opportunity, chose not to exercise the right.

10. Conclusion

The idea that “leave days are automatically lost after 18 months” must be treated with caution.

The Labour Code establishes an 18-month carry-over period for leave not taken for justified reasons, and the rule is that, once the period in which the entitlement could be exercised has expired, it may be extinguished.

However, following ÎCCJ Decision No 40/2026, the analysis cannot stop at the mere passage of time.

For days exceeding the carry-over period, it must be verified why the leave was not taken. If the employer did not give the employee a genuine opportunity to take leave, the right to compensation may survive. If, on the contrary, the employee had that opportunity and deliberately chose not to take the leave, the entitlement may be lost.

At the same time, an allowance in lieu remains an exception: it can arise only upon termination of the employment relationship. The three-year limitation period for claiming the allowance for the days for which the entitlement still exists also starts to run from that point.

From this perspective, employers should no longer view leave management merely as an administrative matter of keeping track of a number of days. Scheduling, informing the employee and the genuine opportunity given to the employee to take leave may become key factors in determining, including in any litigation, whether leave days have been extinguished or must be compensated in money.



Author: P.A.

Views: 596